Sign in
All series

Report Cards for the Pit Walls: One A-Plus and Several Detentions

15 November 2026

Illustration: AI-generated (Google Gemini). Invented characters, not real people.

The columnistsBox, Box, Botherby Ines CarvalhoA recovering strategy engineer marks every pit wall's homework, from Formula 1 to Le Mans.

Ines Carvalho is an invented BossPaddock character, not a real person. The opinions are the character's own and are written to entertain; the facts are checked. All columns

I spent years on a pit wall staring at tyre data and being shouted at over a radio. I am better now. But I still mark everyone else’s homework, and this term’s class has been a mixed bunch.

Ferrari, Mexico City: F, see me

Pole position. A car quick enough to win. And no agreed plan for what happens if both drivers arrive at the first few corners together. So they both left the road, one of them rejoined across the grass and took a five-second penalty, and a Red Bull won the race. Strategy is mostly the art of deciding things before they happen. Ferrari decided afterwards, in a meeting, a week later, in another country. Their own driver has now asked for rules of engagement in writing. When the driver is doing the strategist’s job, somebody upstairs should feel a draught.

Lionspeed, Spa 24 Hours: A-plus, gold star

Engine change on Thursday. Pit-lane start. Sixty-eight cars in front. This is the point where most teams write the weekend off and start drafting the apology to the sponsors. Lionspeed won it, by 12.3 seconds, which after 24 hours is roughly the time it takes to sneeze. You do not come from the pit lane to the top step on speed alone. That is a day of correct calls under safety cars, in traffic, in the dark. Frame it.

Toyota, Le Mans: B, with a note home

They won, so the grade cannot be bad. But asking the leading number 8 car to let the number 7 through, and then watching it take its time, is how you turn a one-two into a family argument. Team orders are fine. Vague team orders, delivered late and obeyed slowly, are how I got my first grey hair. The number 8 crew won the world title anyway, so everybody has a trophy and a grudge. Very Le Mans.

Porsche, Formula E finale: C, effective but ugly

Pascal Wehrlein needed to finish, not to win, and Porsche arranged its cars to make sure he did. He took the title from fourteenth place, with contact along the way and a row afterwards. It worked. It was also the kind of afternoon that makes neutral viewers reach for the remote. A championship won by bodyguard formation counts the same in the record books. It just does not get replayed at the awards dinner.

Red Bull, Sao Paulo: A-minus

Max Verstappen started 21st and finished second. In a wet race, that does not happen without a pit wall getting its calls right, and a driver who treats traffic as a suggestion. The minus is for the paperwork around his team-mate. Isack Hadjar finished third, and RaceFans reports he spent a good part of the race asking whether a position swap with Verstappen would be handed back. If your driver has to keep asking, the instruction was not clear enough the first time.

Mercedes, all season: A, by doing very little

The quietest pit wall of the year belongs to the champions. Two drivers, one of them twenty, allowed to race each other, with the occasional cross word on the radio and no public rulebook drama. The trick with a dominant car is not to invent problems. Mercedes mostly resisted the urge. The exception was reliability, which cost George Russell two finishes and probably the title fight, and no amount of clever strategy fixes a battery.

Rallying: no pit wall, no excuses

A word for the World Rally Championship, where there is no strategist to blame. Three crews finished the season within six points. Elfyn Evans took the title on 243. Oliver Solberg won the final rally and still lost by five. Every one of those points was decided by two people in a car reading notes at speed. I find it refreshing. I also find it terrifying.

Homework for next term

Ferrari: write the rules down. Toyota: say the order once, clearly, early. Porsche: win one from the front. Everyone else: study Lionspeed. The best strategy call of the year was simply refusing to give up on a Thursday.

Your say

Start the argument

Be decent. A first comment is checked before it appears.